HBO’s Harry Potter Remake Can Lastly Repair These 9 Wizarding World Issues That Nonetheless Bug Me Years Later

There are some issues concerning the Wizarding world in Harry Potter which have at all times bugged me, however HBO’s upcoming remake may set them proper. After all, I do not count on any fictional world to be good, particularly one as quirky and eccentric as Harry’s story. For essentially the most half, I’ve accepted these inconsistent or unclear points as a part of the enjoyable. Nevertheless, since HBO’s Harry Potter TV remake has the chance to clear some issues up and finally make the Wizarding world stronger, I believe it ought to take benefit.

A part of what makes the Wizarding world so distinctive relating to fantasy universes is that it is imagined to secretly exist alongside our non-magical communities. This naturally signifies that we readers have a little bit extra room to be important of how this world capabilities. Past this, the distinctive model of magic current in Harry Potter makes issues extra sophisticated. Sure points of Wizarding society established in early books like Harry Potter and the Philosipher’s Stone appeared like no massive deal on the time, however they developed right into a extra vital drawback. It is exactly these items that HBO’s remake should handle.

9

The Wizarding Economic system Makes No Sense

Are There Wizarding Bills We Do not Know About?

Very like the Muggle world, the Wizarding world is split into courses. Households just like the Malfoys are recognized to be extraordinarily rich, whereas the Weasleys are poor. This is a vital issue of Harry Potter, because it emphasizes the desire for pure blood even inside a extra progressive society. Nevertheless, it is obscure how some Wizarding households could be so poor when magic would eradicate essentially the most severe bills.

It is ultimately made clear within the Harry Potter books that meals cannot simply be conjured from nothing (in accordance with Gamp’s Regulation of Elemental Transfiguration). Nevertheless, witches and wizards can improve the amount of meals they have already got, so there is not a lot want for frequent purchasing journeys. Moreover, the Weasleys would not must pay electrical energy, water, or different frequent Muggle utilities. HBO’s Harry Potter remake may clear issues up by revealing a major tax imposed by the Ministry of Magic. This is able to additional the themes of governmentally enforced classism.

8

Schooling In The Wizarding World Is Missing

The Harry Potter Remake Can Clarify How Children Study The Fundamentals

This drawback has been a subject of dialog among the many Harry Potter fandom for years. From our Muggle perspective, Hogwarts’s training lacks the fundamentals. Positive, they’ve Potions, Arithmancy, Transfiguration, and extra, however no math or science courses are provided to the scholars. These would absolutely nonetheless be priceless within the Wizarding world since pure science and the power to calculate sums don’t have anything to do with the presence or lack of magic.

My major argument on this dialogue has at all times been that Wizarding tradition seemingly expects mother and father to show these fundamentals earlier than their youngsters attend Hogwarts. Pupil start their first years realizing easy methods to learn, so their mother and father will need to have taught them, however this might doubtlessly be an issue in some circumstances. HBO’s Harry Potter remake can put a definitive finish to the training dialog by demonstrating how some youngsters get a greater training from their Wizarding mother and father whereas others undergo from neglect on this means (suppose the Gaunts).

7

Sure Spells Ought to Be Manner Extra Of A Drawback

Nothing Is Achieved To Management Harmful Magic

The concept of magically highly effective youngsters is a bit horrifying in Harry Potter. Ron Weasley as soon as talked about that Fred and George practically entrapped him with an Unbreakable Vow, however his father stepped in to cease it. One other Weasley catastrophe concerned the twins remodeling Ron’s teddy right into a spider, scarring him for all times. These have been principally comical anecdotes, however they have been a reminder of a really actual drawback within the Wizarding world.

It is unusual that issues like Unbreakable Vows or the Unforgivable Curses aren’t abused extra within the Wizarding World. Although the Ministry of Magic screens magic use, Harry Potter demonstrates that this turns into extra sophisticated in magical households and communities. The Harry Potter remake should by some means clarify how the magical group does not fall to items when everybody, even youngsters, has entry to a lot energy.

6

Different Wizarding Spells Are Utterly Redundant

What Even Is The Level Of Locked Doorways?

Harry Potter is stuffed with helpful spells, however some are too helpful. A main instance of that is Alohomora, a spell to unlock locks. Hermione launched readers to this spell in Harry Potter and the Thinker’s Stone when she used it to unlock the door that stored college students separated from Fluffy and the opposite protections across the Thinker’s Stone. She stated she examine it within the “Normal E book of Spells,” indicating that this is likely one of the Wizarding world’s most elementary spells.

If first-year wizards can grasp Alohomora, why does anybody within the Wizarding world hassle with locks? The spell makes itself solely redundant. HBO’s Harry Potter remake may handle this by introducing a tiered talent system for each locks and the spell itself. There have to be extra to it than pointing a wand at any outdated lock and muttering “Alohomora.” Some locks (actually most locks) have to be impervious to the spell.

5

The Wizarding Inhabitants Appears Far Too Small

The Numbers Aren’t Constant

One unclear side of Harry Potter is the dimensions of the Wizarding world by way of inhabitants. The books subtly handle this, noting that everybody within the British magical group is aware of each other and is acquainted with the outstanding households. Additionally they notice that the concept of blood purity has grow to be unsustainable since there are now not sufficient witches and wizards for pure bloods to procreate amongst themselves. Nonetheless, the numbers, particularly inside Hogwarts, are inconsistent.

J.Okay. Rowling has stated there are about 1,000 college students at Hogwarts, with roughly 250 college students per home. Nevertheless, there are solely 5 Gryffindor boys in Harry’s 12 months, fairly than the about 40 that ought to have been for the 1,000 determine to make sense. Moreover, if there have been so many college students, there would not be practically sufficient lecturers at Hogwarts to make sense. HBO’s remake must both considerably scale back the variety of children attending Hogwarts—together with these in Harry’s dorm—or considerably improve the variety of employees.

4

Wizarding World Authorized Restrictions Are Extremely Inconsistent

We May Use Extra Data About The Legal guidelines & Rules

Loads of foolish issues are unlawful in Harry Potter, however there’s a lot extra that ought to be towards the legislation however, for some purpose, is not. Potions are a chief instance since issues just like the Polyjuice Potion, Felix Felicis, and others are authorized to make use of. Positive, they’re regulated, however even this does not make a lot sense. There is no such thing as a trustworthy purpose that somebody would wish to faux to be another person, so why is not the Polyjuice Potion outlawed solely?

Enchanting Muggle artifacts to do hurt can be an enormous no-no in Harry Potter, but it surely’s infrequently enforced. Borgin and Burke is stuffed stuffed with unlawful gadgets (together with the remainder of Knockturn Alley), however the Ministry does nothing about it. The Harry Potter remake should set up additional legal guidelines and restrictions to clarify why harmful exercise is not stopped by the Ministry (whereas seemingly innocent conduct is punished).

3

Portrait Magic & Shifting Footage Are Puzzling

Are They Folks Or Not?

When you concentrate on it, transferring portraits and footage in Harry Potter are fairly disturbing. Although pictures within the Every day Prophet appear to be extra like video seize on a loop, private images and portraits have a character all their very own. That is particularly odd when contemplating Hogwarts’ work. The Fats Woman, Sir Cadogan, and others are characters in their very own proper, with personalities, pals, and even the power to get drunk on painted wine. The Headmaster portraits in Dumbledore’s workplace possess the personalities of their topics, however are they really actual folks?

Dumbledore’s portrait continued to information Snape after the headmaster’s demise, and Harry even conferred with the portray on the finish of Deathly Hallows. Evidently depictions of individuals “dwelling on” as work can be considerably complicated and emotional within the Wizarding world. Why would not everybody have a portray made? The Harry Potter remake can element the constraints of work in comparison with dwelling folks.

2

The Justice System Is Extraordinarily Extreme In The Wizarding World

Aren’t There Different, Much less Intense Prisons?

Punishments within the Wizarding world are fairly outrageous and inconsistent. Azkaban is the one jail ever talked about, and it’s solely run by the Dementors. Witches and wizards are thrown in right here to be tortured and wither away if they’re discovered responsible of harming others with Darkish magic, however way more minor offenses are punished the identical means. It is a bit excessive, however that is all of the stranger when contemplating how Hogwarts expulsion works.

College students could be expelled from Hogwarts for varied causes and are not allowed to get their magical training elsewhere. The truth is, their wands are destroyed, and they’re forbidden from training magic altogether. Oddly, harmful wizards who’re sentenced to Azkaban aren’t at risk of getting their wands destroyed. Sirius, Bellatrix, and each different escaped Loss of life Eater reclaimed their wands as soon as they have been free. On the very least, the Harry Potter remake ought to acknowledge the injustice of all of it.

1

Wizarding Medical Care Appears Weirdly Restricted

HBO’s Harry Potter Remake Can Clarify The Restrictions

Folks usually complain that there’s little regard for security within the Harry Potter sequence, however I’ve at all times argued that this is smart in a world the place accidents could be magically healed. For essentially the most half, witches and wizards could be healed of significant accidents and diseases with the wave of a wand or a swig of potion. Harry even had the bones in his arm regrown in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets and techniques.

There are unusual limits to magical therapeutic, nevertheless. Muggles have developed the know-how to repair an individual’s eyesight, however that is, apparently, past the talents of magic. Harry and plenty of different witches and wizards put on glasses, indicating that there is no such thing as a magical remedy for nearsightedness or astigmatism. If that is the best way it’s, so be it. Nevertheless, it could be good if HBO’s Harry Potter remake acknowledged why eyesight is past fixing within the Wizarding world.