Scandal hits the comics artwork world as widespread cowl artist Rian Gonzales faces accusations of tracing one other artist’s authentic work for an upcoming variant cowl of ULTIMATE SPIDER-MAN #15. The controversy facilities on claims that Gonzales deliberately traced the work by an artist generally known as Nina, who drew this piece as a birthday current to an artist good friend named Juby.
Right here’s Gonzales’ aspect of the story later referred to on X as a response to “backlash and violent reactions”.
Based on all events concerned, efforts had been made to resolve this difficulty peacefully and offline. Nonetheless, each Nina and Juby have raised considerations concerning the semantics surrounding the state of affairs. Regardless of Gonzales’ claims on the contrary, the problem stays vital—largely as a result of the artist denies tracing and insists they had been solely referencing, which blurs the strains additional.
You’ll be able to examine the unique and canopy paintings under to type your individual opinion.
Each Juby and Nina have rightfully acknowledged on-line that this kind of habits shouldn’t be condoned. Skilled artists ought to by no means copy different’s work and declare it as their very own, particularly to an enormous writer similar to Marvel. To name it out would assist the trade for the higher general and for what it’s price, Nina has additionally gone out of the way in which to share sources for artists searching for references together with utilizing for pictures and acon3d.com/en for a reference library. It also needs to be famous that every one 3 of those persons are skilled artists who’ve revealed for main firms – so this kind of traction wouldn’t possible happen had it been a smaller indie creator that was traced.
Gonzales’ paintings has risen in reputation up to now ten years revealed in locations like Marvel, DC, Growth, and Archie, after which hit a large viewers being featured in her variant playing cards within the online game Marvel Snap. As to how lengthy she’s traced or copied others’ authentic paintings, that difficulty has now come into query. Based on Juby, Gonzales has additionally gone on to delete different works on her socials since talking with Nina.
Nonetheless, no matter what comes out of this, I and everybody inevitably concerned in reporting on this should stress to followers: don’t be that individual that outcomes to bullying or hate. Be dissatisfied. Converse out in opposition to what’s unfair. However by no means consequence to threats over fandom.
I say this as a result of many individuals are followers of Rian Gonzales’ paintings and heritage, particularly concerning her Filipino background, as a lot of her shade work could be traced to paint palettes which can be fairly native to the Philippines. She’s actually beloved over there (talking as a Filipino myself) and when you don’t know this, our individuals have a longstanding historical past of manufacturing a number of the greatest comedian artists within the trade. There’s a big diploma of delight right here. And a much bigger fandom than the typical American comics particular person most likely realizes.
Accountability for positive. Apologies most undoubtedly. Although above all else, Gonzales wants to handle the problem about tracing versus referencing.
